Mel Schwartz · the view from the therapy room
The subjective turn: E‑Prime, taken personally.
E-Prime grew out of the machinery of thought: Korzybski's structural differential maps the ladder every verdict climbs, and his student D. David Bourland, Jr. banned the verb that lets a speaker skip it. Mel Schwartz, psychotherapist, couples counsellor and author of The Possibility Principle, arrived through the other door: the damage the little verb does in ordinary lives, from marriages stuck in right-versus-wrong to self-talk that seals a verdict on the self. He has used E-Prime with clients for decades, and he generously gave this group a long conversation about how. This page collects his angle: E-Prime as a way to live with people, starting with yourself.
One bedtime exchange runs through this page. Mel's own origin story, from years before he ever met the word E-Prime. His first marriage, lights out. He says: “It's hot in here.” She answers: “No, it's not. It's cold.” Full stop. Nowhere left to go.
The repair, when it finally came to him, took three words: “I feel hot.” She can't tell him he doesn't feel hot. Nothing remained to argue about.
Right versus wrong: the ping-pong
Mel opens his couples work with one question: do you want your words received and considered, or do you want them to fall on deaf ears? The human mind, he says, defaults to right-versus-wrong, and nobody volunteers to play the wrong one. An objective sentence, “it is hot in here”, stakes a claim about the shared world, which hands your listener a standing invitation: contest it. What follows, Mel calls a ping-pong match. It goes nowhere, and every rally wears the relationship down a little more.
A subjective sentence changes the game entirely. “I feel hot” reports on my territory, and no one else can speak for it. You can dispute my judgement about the room; you can't dispute my report of my own skin. Speak in perceptions and feelings (“I feel…”, “I think…”, “I see it as…”) and, as Mel puts it, no one can say to you: “you're wrong.” Nothing to defend, so nothing to attack, and the other person can finally afford to listen.
Here the grammar comes in: sentences that begin subjectively contain no “to be”. Mel cheerfully calls his own method a sleight of hand: most of his clients never hear the term E-Prime at all. They learn to speak subjectively, and the banned verb simply never turns up. E-Prime and the subjective turn amount to the same move seen from two sides: one bans the verb and ownership follows; the other asks for ownership and the verb quietly vanishes.
The sentence you say to yourself
In a course Mel taught, he asked the group to name the core beliefs that limited them. A man who had never spoken before stood up and offered his: “I am a loser.” Mel asked him to say it again without the “am”. He found: “I usually feel like a loser.” His face changed as he said it: “that makes me feel hopeful. I could change how I feel.” On another evening a man went from “I am nothing; I am empty” to “I feel like nothing; I feel empty”, and lightened visibly, because what he felt, however deeply embedded over a lifetime, now looked alterable.
The grammar does real work in that shift. “I am X” welds the verdict straight onto the self: no date, no context, no exit; a label posing as an identity. “I feel X when Y” hangs the same content on a hinge: owned (mine, not the universe's), dated (today, not forever), conditional (when Y, so Y can change). And a feeling, unlike an essence, can change. Readers of the differential page will recognise the shape at once: the welded label collapses two levels of abstraction into one; the hinged one keeps person and label distinct: joined, visible, separable. A tag on a string.
Mel treats this as the heart of self-esteem work. “I am a loser” casts you as the victim of a fixed fact about the world. “I feel like a loser when I miss my goals” hands the authorship back, and invites the questions that make change possible: why then? since when? what might shift it? If you've read our website's “Kinder to yourself” card, you've met this idea already; it comes straight from Mel.
Labels, diagnoses, and other people
The same weld does quieter damage in the third person. “John is bipolar” reduces a father, son, husband and friend to a single word, and the word names a category we invented. Mel borrows Whitehead's phrase misplaced concreteness: we coin an idea, harden it into a thing, then collapse a human into the thing. Remove the verb and the honest version has to surface: “when I spoke with John, his behaviour seemed consistent with what we call bipolar.” Longer, yes, and suddenly the observer, the context and the category's man-made label all appear in the sentence, available for questioning.
The move works identically at home: “Bill is a selfish husband” → “Bill seems self-centred to me.” The first passes judgement on Bill; the second opens a conversation about us, and leaves Bill room to differ from his label tomorrow.
“The only verbs that show no movement. They are inert. They are fixed. They stagnate. And hence we stagnate.”
Finding your voice
Mel coined a companion term: other-esteem: the everyday habit of feeling good about yourself only when others approve of you, which keeps the real thing permanently out of reach. People trapped there rehearse every sentence in the safety of their own heads before daring to say it (he calls it a silent stutter) because the objective voice sustains the fear: every claim of fact risks correction, and their standing feels staked on getting it right.
The subjective voice removes the risk. Share a perception, “here's how I see it”, and no one holds the authority to correct you; your vantage point needs no defence and owes no apology. Mel has watched clients who spent years hesitating learn to speak with conviction this way: starting a sentence without a plan for how it will end, trusting one word to inform the next, letting a voice emerge. Confidence, on this view, doesn't come from finally possessing the facts. It comes from noticing you never needed them to speak.
And the same door leads to the harder gift: vulnerability. Mel treats it as the engine of self-worth: “here's my insecurity; I'd rather share it than spend the evening managing what I think you think of me.” Sentences like that carry feelings, perceptions and ownership, which makes them, notice, E-Prime sentences. The grammar and the courage go together.
When to reach for it
Mel doesn't speak E-Prime all day, and doesn't ask anyone else to. He reaches for it selectively, “when an awareness kicks in” that a moment calls for thought: a hard conversation, a feeling that needs saying, a verdict quietly forming about himself or someone else. (He also waves the auxiliaries through without guilt: asked on the phone what he does mid-drive, he declines to torture “I'm driving” into a pretzel.) Chris and Roger came away from the call with the same rule in fewer words: use it when you need to hear yourself, and when you need to get heard.
But a reflex you never drilled tends not to show up when you need it. Speaking subjectively under pressure, mid-argument or mid-meeting, takes exactly the kind of practice this group exists for. If you'd like to try it on: the checker will count your “is”es as you type, the coach will spar with you gently, and the group would love your company when we start.
Where Mel's frame goes further than ours needs to. Mel houses all of this inside a larger worldview drawn from quantum physics: reality as flow and potential, and the moment a possibility hardens into a fixed identity as a kind of wave collapse. Asked on our call whether he means the physics as metaphor or as mechanism, he answered, cheerfully: “both.” Hold that as lightly or as literally as you like. The relational method (speak subjectively, own the perception, unweld the label) stands on its own: decades of consulting-room evidence, plus a daily experiment anyone can run at home tonight, free of charge. E-Prime even supplies the agnosticism: say how things seem to you, and leave what “is” to the physicists.
Korzybski gave this group its theory; Mel gives it the reason most people will actually come: the sentences we say at bedtime and inside our own heads, and how much kinder they can get, one dropped “is” at a time.